Skip to main content

​
Your Winning Arguments

Most government contractors lose because they talk about what they do instead of why the customer should care. Win themes are the compelling arguments that make the customer want to choose you. Discriminators are the unique advantages that make it impossible for them to choose anyone else. The hard truth: Companies with strong, differentiated messages win 60% more contracts than those who just list their capabilities and hope for the best.
Win themes solve the customer’s problems. Discriminators prove you’re the only one who can solve them this well.

​
What Makes Customers Say “Yes”

​
The Four Tests Every Win Theme Must Pass

Your themes must pass all four tests or they’re just marketing fluff:

Solves Their Real Problem

Addresses what keeps them up at night, not what you think is cool about your solution.

Competitors Can't Say It

Something only you can claim convincingly - if everyone can say it, it’s not a theme.

You Can Prove It

Backed by specific examples, numbers, and results they can verify and trust.

Actually Matters to Them

Directly impacts how they’ll score your proposal and make their decision.

​
Win Theme Categories

Focus on how you enhance the customer’s mission success:
  • Improved operational efficiency and productivity
  • Enhanced mission readiness and capability
  • Reduced operational risks and increased reliability
  • Better outcomes and measurable performance improvements
Example: “Our proven logistics system reduces supply chain delays by 40%, ensuring your critical missions have the equipment they need when they need it.”
Emphasize financial benefits and value creation:
  • Lower total cost of ownership
  • Faster implementation reducing costs
  • Efficiency improvements saving money
  • Risk reduction avoiding costly failures
Example: “Our automated processes eliminate 60% of manual tasks, saving $2.3M annually in labor costs while reducing errors by 95%.”
Address customer concerns about potential problems:
  • Proven track record in similar environments
  • Robust security and compliance frameworks
  • Redundancy and backup systems
  • Change management and transition planning
Example: “Our cybersecurity framework has protected DoD networks for 15 years without a single successful breach, including during three major nation-state campaigns.”
Highlight technical advantages and future-ready solutions:
  • Cutting-edge technology implementations
  • Scalable and adaptable architectures
  • Future-proofing and technology evolution
  • Research and development capabilities
Example: “Our AI-powered analytics identify threats 10x faster than traditional methods, turning reactive security into predictive protection.”

​
Developing Win Themes

​
Step 1: Customer Analysis

Understand what drives customer decisions:
1

Identify Hot Buttons

What keeps the customer awake at night?
  • Mission-critical challenges they face
  • Budget pressures and efficiency needs
  • Compliance or regulatory requirements
  • Political or stakeholder pressures
2

Analyze Evaluation Criteria

How will proposals be scored?
  • Technical evaluation factors and weights
  • Past performance importance and criteria
  • Cost evaluation methodology
  • Management and organizational factors
3

Research Stakeholder Priorities

What matters to different decision influencers?
  • Contracting officer concerns
  • Technical evaluator priorities
  • End user operational needs
  • Senior leadership strategic objectives

​
Step 2: Competitive Differentiation

Position against likely competitors: Competitive Intelligence Analysis:
  • What will competitors emphasize in their themes?
  • Where are competitors vulnerable or weak?
  • What unique advantages do you possess?
  • How can you “ghost” competitor weaknesses?
Ghosting Techniques:
  • Highlight requirements where competitors struggle
  • Emphasize criteria where you excel uniquely
  • Address risks that competitors present
  • Showcase capabilities competitors lack

​
Step 3: Evidence Development

Support themes with concrete proof: Types of Evidence:
  • Quantified Results: Specific metrics and improvements
  • Past Performance: Relevant contract examples
  • References: Customer testimonials and quotes
  • Certifications: Standards compliance and approvals
  • Awards: Recognition and industry honors
Evidence Quality Check:
  • Is it specific and quantifiable?
  • Is it relevant to this customer/mission?
  • Is it recent and current?
  • Can competitors make similar claims?

​
Your Unfair Advantages

​
What Makes You Impossible to Ignore

Discriminators are your secret weapons - the things only you can do that competitors can’t match. They’re not just better capabilities, they’re advantages that make you the obvious choice. Real discriminators must be:
  1. Only Yours: If your competitor can make the same claim, it’s not a discriminator
  2. Actually Important: Something the customer cares about in their decision
  3. Undeniably True: You can prove it with evidence they can verify
  4. Hard to Copy: Not something competitors can quickly replicate or match

​
Types of Discriminators

Proprietary Technology:
  • Patent-protected innovations
  • Proprietary algorithms or methods
  • Unique technical approaches
  • Exclusive technology partnerships
Performance Advantages:
  • Superior speed, accuracy, or efficiency
  • Unique capability combinations
  • Scalability or flexibility advantages
  • Integration capabilities others lack
Example: “Our patented compression algorithm reduces data transmission time by 75% compared to industry standards, enabling real-time battlefield intelligence sharing.”
Relevant Experience:
  • Identical or highly similar contract experience
  • Same customer successful performance
  • Unique mission or environment experience
  • Scale or complexity advantages
Performance Excellence:
  • Perfect CPARS ratings over multiple contracts
  • Zero security incidents over X years
  • Awards or recognition for exceptional performance
  • Customer testimonials highlighting unique value
Example: “We are the only contractor to achieve ‘Exceptional’ ratings on all five DoD enterprise IT contracts over the past decade, demonstrating unmatched reliability.”
Key Personnel:
  • Industry-recognized experts and thought leaders
  • Former government officials with insider knowledge
  • Technical innovators with unique expertise
  • Team combinations competitors cannot match
Organizational Capabilities:
  • Unique organizational structure or approach
  • Specialized facilities or equipment
  • Security clearance depth and breadth
  • Geographic presence advantages
Example: “Our program manager is the former Navy CIO who designed the architecture we’ll be supporting, providing unmatched system knowledge.”
Socioeconomic Status:
  • Small business advantages and set-aside eligibility
  • Veteran-owned, woman-owned, or other certifications
  • HUBZone or other geographic advantages
  • Unique partnership or teaming arrangements
Financial and Operational:
  • Financial strength and stability ratings
  • Insurance and bonding capabilities
  • Facility security clearances and approvals
  • Quality system certifications (ISO, CMMI, etc.)
Example: “As the only Service-Disabled Veteran-Owned Small Business with Top Secret facility clearance in the region, we provide both set-aside advantages and security capability.”

​
Win Theme Development Process

​
Theme Brainstorming

Generate potential themes through structured sessions:
  1. Customer Perspective Exercise: What would make the customer’s job easier?
  2. Competitive Analysis: What can we say that competitors cannot?
  3. Strength Inventory: What are our unique capabilities and advantages?
  4. Evidence Mapping: What proof points support our claims?

​
Theme Validation

Test themes against quality criteria:
1

Customer Relevance Test

  • Does this address a known customer priority?
  • Would this influence their buying decision?
  • Is this theme important in their evaluation?
2

Competitive Differentiation Test

  • Can competitors make the same claim?
  • Does this highlight our unique advantages?
  • Does this ghost competitor weaknesses?
3

Evidence Strength Test

  • Do we have strong proof points?
  • Is our evidence specific and quantifiable?
  • Can we demonstrate this credibly?
4

Message Clarity Test

  • Is the benefit to customer clear?
  • Can we explain this in simple terms?
  • Does this create a compelling story?

​
Theme Prioritization

Rank themes by impact and strength: Primary Themes (2-3 maximum):
  • Most important to customer decision
  • Strongest competitive differentiation
  • Best evidence and proof points
  • Core to your value proposition
Secondary Themes (3-4 maximum):
  • Supporting and reinforcing messages
  • Address specific evaluation criteria
  • Counter competitive threats
  • Demonstrate breadth of capabilities
Supporting Themes (as needed):
  • Address minor evaluation factors
  • Provide additional proof points
  • Round out complete story
  • Handle objections or concerns

​
Integration with Capture Strategy

​
Messaging Consistency

Ensure themes are reinforced across all activities: Capture Planning:
  • Themes drive solution development decisions
  • Guide customer engagement messaging
  • Inform partnership and teaming strategies
  • Shape proposal outline and structure
Customer Interactions:
  • Consistent messaging in all customer meetings
  • Presentation materials reinforce themes
  • Q&A responses support theme narratives
  • Written communications echo themes
Proposal Development:
  • Themes integrated into executive summary
  • Technical approach demonstrates themes
  • Past performance examples support themes
  • Management approach reinforces themes

​
Theme Evolution

Refine themes based on customer feedback: Feedback Sources:
  • Customer meetings and discussions
  • Industry day insights and reactions
  • Competitor intelligence and positioning
  • Proposal evaluator perspectives (post-award)
Adaptation Process:
  • Monitor customer reactions to messaging
  • Adjust emphasis based on feedback
  • Add new evidence as it becomes available
  • Refine language for clarity and impact

​
Measuring Theme Effectiveness

​
Customer Validation Indicators

Signs that themes are resonating:
  • Positive Feedback: Customer acknowledges benefits
  • Follow-up Questions: Customers want more details
  • Reference Requests: Customers ask for proof points
  • Competitive Inquiries: Customers compare to competitors

​
Proposal Success Metrics

Evaluate theme success through proposal outcomes:
  • Evaluation Scores: High scores in relevant areas
  • Debriefing Feedback: Evaluator comments on strengths
  • Competitive Analysis: How themes performed vs. competitors
  • Win/Loss Analysis: Theme effectiveness in decisions

​
Common Theme Development Mistakes

​
Feature-Focused Themes

Avoid: “We have the latest XYZ technology” Better: “Our advanced XYZ technology reduces your processing time by 50%, enabling faster mission response”

​
Generic Claims

Avoid: “We provide quality service and support” Better: “Our 24/7 support team resolves 95% of issues within 2 hours, ensuring your operations never stop”

​
Unsubstantiated Claims

Avoid: “We are the best in the industry” Better: “Gartner ranked us #1 in customer satisfaction for three consecutive years in this market segment”

​
Competitor-Matchable Claims

Avoid: “We have experienced staff” Better: “Our team includes the original system architects who designed 60% of your current infrastructure”
Ready to learn about price-to-win analysis strategies?